Teddy’s Bar and Grill Brooklyn Fry Review — Oldest Bar in Williamsburg (2025)

Teddy’s Bar and Grill Brooklyn Fry Review begins at the legendary Teddy’s — a Williamsburg icon serving burgers, beer, and fries inside the oldest continuously operating bar in Brooklyn, active since 1887.

Frank and Pauly (FHK Fries) rolled in to see if the history and hype line up. Brooklyn locals swear Teddy’s represents the “old Williamsburg” — a neighborhood bar with real wood, real history, and plates built for comfort. We were ready to find out.